What Do You Think?

What do you guys think of the knee-highs for fall?  I really like them, actually, but it's not a look I'm itching to try.  To me they run a close resemblance to Cher's knee-highs in Clueless. 

 They're risky. Though it seems the key to pulling off this look depends on the spacing from your short/skirt to your knee-highs.  The closer they are, the better.  (Or am I just a prude?) I think the model below (the one with the suspenders) plays this look off safely.  

(too short)

(a little better...)

(safety!)

Anyway, what do you think?  I think I'd rather wear this:

{all photos via studdedhearts}

Happy Friday!